Wednesday, 22 October 2008

"To a Mouse" by Robert Burns

Why do you think Robert Burns feel sorry for the mouse? Explain in 50 or so words, referring to the poem where you can.

3 comments:

emily_k said...

In verse one the poet tells us that the creature is frightened- "tim'rous beastie", "panic's in thy breastie!". This shows the poet feels sorry for the mouse because it is so frightened.

The poet also makes it clear that one reason he feels sorry for the mouse is that "Man's dominion Has broken Nature's social union". This means that he is ashamed of the fact that humans and their tools (i.e. his plough) have destroyed the balance of nature (i.e. the mouses nest).

In verse four the poet implies he pities the mouse because it has to cope with bad weather- "win's are strewin", "foggage green", "December's winds".

In the next verse he talks about how he has ruined the mouses nest- "Thou thought to dwell, Till crash!". This language is dramatic because he uses an exlimation to show a sudden event and panic. This paragraph shows the poet feels sorry for what he has done.

The poet goes on to say how the mouse has taken alot of time to build his nest "has cost thee many a weary nibble!" which increases how he feels sorry for the mouse because he has ruined the mouse's hard work.

The next verse is slightly different because the poet identifies with the mouse saying that "no thy lane" (i.e. the poet is in a simular position to the mouse)- "the bes laid schemes o' Mice an' Men Gang aft a-gley". This verse shows empathy between the poet and the mouse as their plans are often ruined.

The last verse actually flips the poem on its head. Whereas the poem starts with the poet saying how he feels very sorry for the mouse, it ends with the poet saying he envies it- "thou art blest, compar'd wi' me!". The poet thinks the mouse is lucky that it only cares about the present- "the present only toucheth thee"- whereas the farmer has to remember the past- "I backwards cast my e'e"- and think about the future- "An' foward, tho' I canna see,"

Mr Benn said...

Thank you for starting this off, and well done for showing such a strong grasp and appreciation of the poem...the Scots words actually seem to have helped rather than hindered you! Now, the rest of you, if you've been looking and holding off, it's time to be leave a comment!

alice webber said...

Robert Burns shows us why he feels sorry for the mouse in the first verse, 'Wee, sleekit, cowrin, tim'rous beastie'. This shows that the poet feels sorry for the mouse because it appears to be scared and frightened.

It is also shown that the poet feels sorry for the mouse in verse two when the poet writes 'Man's dominion Has broken Nature's social union'. This shows that he feels that men have unsettled the balance of nature (habitates) with the use of human equipment.

A final point that shows that Robert Burns feels sorry for the mouse is in paragraph 5. 'Thou saw the fields laid bare an' waste'. This could show that the poet knows that the mouse will not survive on the harsh conditions that winter will bring. This could also show the way mens equipment e.g. plows has made the land so unhabitable that it would be impossible for the mouse to live on.